Post by Brian RunningPost by Derek TearnePost by 2) First make sure the truss ros is adjusted properly.
You've got this all the wrong way round. This is the *last* step, and
the step that is *least* suitable for an amateur to attempt on a brand
new bass.
Derek, with the above statement, you disqualified yourself from giving
any advice on bass set-up. If you do not know how to adjust a truss rod
and set up a bass, please do not give advice on this newsgroup as if you
do know what you're talking about.
I know perfectly well how to adjust a truss rod and set up a bass. I
wrecked my first guitar neck through over-adjusting the truss rod 25
years ago - it wasn't my guitar. If the internet had been available in
those days I'd like to think someone would have given me the advice I've
just given here. Adjust the action using the bridge *before* messing
with the truss rod.
If the truss rod needs to be adjusted and this is ones first ever
attempt at setting up a bass *get a tech to do it*.
Why is this wrong advice?
Post by Brian RunningNewbies and inexperienced players
come here for advice from experienced players. Steve's advice was sound.
Steve's advice was sound *assuming* the person taking the advice already
knows how to do the steps required.
As a checklist for a competent tech or apprentice on setting up a bass
for a client it's excellent - apart from some small ommissions.
As advice to a newbie it's not, in my opinion, good advice. Especially
as a response to a question specifically on how to set intonation.
If his advice had been "Check the relief, in the unlikely event it
really needs adjusting find a tech or experienced friend and get them to
do this for you" I wouldn't have so much problem with it. However,
there are far far too many people on this forum suggesting truss rod
adjustment as a first step.
It's like telling someone who's just bought a classic sportscar that
isn't running right that the first step is to attempt to balance those
twin SU carburettors. Yes, in the fullness of time they need to be
balanced, but try putting oil in the dashpot first!
Going beyond the issue of advising newbies to adjust truss rods there is
also the philosophical issue of whether the relief should be set before
or after the action. Some say adjust the neck first, others say adjust
the action first and then set the relief accordingly - personally I'm in
the latter camp but I suppose I shouldn't quibble with people who want
to do it the other way round.
And certainly the intonation will need to be adjusted after adjusting
the relief or action - so if you *have* to do both then it makes sense
to adjust the intonation last.
However, if the only obvious problem is that the intonation is out then
*adjust the intonation first*. If you end up with a bass that is well
intonated, there may be no need to do the other steps.
So, I'll make it very clear.
My advice to NEWBIES wishing to attempt guitar setup is this.
1) Do the simple steps first - these being action and intonation.
2) Address the obvious issues first - in this case intonation. You're
doing this yourself so there's no time pressure to do all the steps in
the most time and cost efficient order.
3) If you get to a position where you think you need to either a) tweak
the truss rod or b) recut the nut slots *get some advice from a local
who can actually look at the instrument*. It's great having all these
experienced people on the internet giving sage advice without being able
to glance at your instrument - but they might give very different advice
if they could actually see your bass.
4) Don't do anything you can't reverse and make notes of each step you
make eg. how many turns of the bridge screw you made and in which
direction.
5) If you're thinking of rewiring anything, or replacing pots or pickups
*take digital photographs of the wiring in working condition*, in the
old day when we made our own fun I'd have suggested making colour coded
drawings. Digital photos are best though.
6) If you seem to have completely messed up take it to a tech, or
experienced friend and get them to sort it out. Don't be embarrased
about this. You can always say "It came like this from Fender" and
they'll probably even believe you - as long as you haven't got
screwdriver scratches all over the place or snapped the truss rod.
Which reminds me of something almost no one ever mentions when giving
sage advice on setups on the internet. Before going near any of those
bridge height or intonation screws put masking tape over any paint that
could get potentially scratched by your screwdriver.
Tell me, where, exactly, is that advice flawed?
--- Derek
--
Derek Tearne - ***@url.co.nz
Many Hands - Trans Cultural Music from Aotearoa/New Zealand
http://www.manyhands.co.nz/